Right and left clash over the cost of Burnham’s EU reset
UK media put a price on Britain’s EU reset on Tuesday, adopting different coverage based on their political leaning.
The reset is a set of limited agreements to reduce trade barriers created by Brexit. It is not a move to rejoin the EU, though Prime Minister Andy Burnham has said he will put options on closer ties to voters later.
The Times reported that Britain could face a multimillion-pound “Farage penalty” if a future government withdraws from the food and farming agreement Burnham is due to sign in Brussels on Friday. The deal would remove most routine checks on food, animal and plant exports, in return for Britain keeping its standards aligned with EU rules.
Earlier this year, the Financial Times suggested a withdrawing party would cover the cost of reinstating controls and infrastructure. A senior EU source said such clauses are common and would apply equally if Brussels withdrew. UK government sources called it routine and mutual; reform UK leader Nigel Farage called it “wholly illegitimate”, argued that no government can bind its successor, and said he would renege on the deal as prime minister.
The Guardian covered the cost of rejoining, examining a claim by Stay Out, a campaign launched last week by a former Vote Leave research director, that membership would cost £750m a week.
The figure, rounded from £756m, is based on the Commission’s proposed €2tn budget for 2028-34, while member states are discussing a €1.62tn compromise. It assumes Britain would repay pandemic-era EU borrowing, which the Guardian calls questionable, and that the rebate would not return, which it calls fair. Vote Leave’s £350m claim was reprimanded by the UK Statistics Authority in 2016.
Neither bill is one Britain currently faces. The penalty arises only on withdrawal, and the £750m only on rejoining, which Burnham has ruled out before the next election. The Centre for European Reform estimates the cost of being outside the EU at £3bn-£3.5bn a week in lost national income.
The Times built its story around Farage, using a label UK government sources dispute. Commentary from the right asked why a good deal would need a fine to keep Britain in it, and the Spectator ran Stay Out’s £750m as a flat headline. The Guardian tested that number against the 2016 bus claim and found it selective. Centrist and left-leaning coverage has tended to carry the government’s line that the clause is standard and mutual. One side reads a trap for a future elected government. The other reads ordinary treaty small print and a cost claim that does not stand up.
Is £750m a week the real cost of rejoining the EU – or the Brexit bus myth all over again?
UK faces ‘Farage penalty’ if it pulls out of Brexit reset deal
Johnson: Britain would vote for Brexit again
Even Red Ed admits that cosying up to Brussels will come at a cost for Britain
Fury as UK will be forced to pay ‘Farage penalty’ if it pulls out of Brexit deal
Brits gave their verdict on Brexit 10 years ago Burnham & it WASN’T try again
Britain could be forced to pay EU multi-million-pound ‘Nigel Farage penalty’ if Andy Burnham’s Brexit surrender deal collapses
Editorial credit: John Gomez / Shutterstock.com


